How To Build A Dr. Beverly Crusher Commander Deck

Dr. Beverly Crusher is definitely my favorite lifegain commander from Star Trek. Her design is fairly simple, and it almost feels like a card that was designed from the bottom up. That’s a feeling we don’t get often with Universes Beyond. I’d try her in the 99 of just about any lifegain deck that can play white, but I wanted to see how far I could push her from the command zone.

For my build, I wanted as many ways as possible to turn a little bit of life into something else. Sometimes that’s a card, sometimes it’s a pair of +1/+1 counters, and sometimes it’s a very large Doctor. There’s also a small legendary creature package that gives us a reason to spread those counters around.

Commander Overview

Dr. Beverly Crusher is a three-mana 2/2 Human Doctor that gives you an extra trigger whenever gaining life causes a triggered ability of a permanent you control to trigger. That includes her own ability, which puts a +1/+1 counter on her whenever you gain life. If you play Ajani’s Welcome on turn one and Crusher on turn three, the Welcome gains you one life as she enters, and Crusher gains two counters. That’s a 4/4 on turn three from a single point of life.

The distinction I’d keep in mind is how often you gain life. Gaining five life in one event gives you two Crusher triggers. Whereas gaining one life give separate times gives you ten! Cards that double the amount of life you gain still have a place here, but I want cheap, repeatable sources that give Crusher more chances to do her thing.

Main Deck Strategy

I like opening with a cheap lifegain source, then following it up with Crusher or another creature that rewards me for gaining life. Once both pieces are in piece, even an opponent playing a creature can help build my board.

Gain Life

Soul Warden, Hinterland Sanctifier, and Ajani’s Welcome give you something to do on turn one. Soul Warden also sees creatures your opponents play, which means you can grow Crusher while your mana is still tapped from your last turn. Authority of the Consuls does something similar on the other side of the table and makes opposing creatures enter tapped, giving you a little extra time to set up.

I also like getting lifegain out of slots I’d already be playing. Pristine Talisman ramps and gains a life whenever you tap it for mana. Radiant Fountain gives you a trigger off a land drop, and Brokers Hideout, Cabaretti Courtyard, and Obscura Storefront find a Plains and gain a life. With Koth of the Homestead out, a Hideout gives you separate life gains for the two lands entering and the Hideout’s own ability. The Plains also gives you a counter through Koth’s other ability.

Cast Legendary Creatures

The legends I want early already help the lifegain plan. Haliya, Guided by Light gives me a life when she or another creature or artifact I control enters, and Dr. Pulaski, Cynical Clinician gains four life when I draw my second card in a turn. The Seriema can find whichever legend I’m missing. If I need a source of life, I’ll look for Haliya or Koth. If I already have the life coming in, Heliod, Sun-Crowned gives me a place to put all those counters.

Aerith Gainsborough is the reason I especially like having a few legends out together. She grows alongside Crusher, and when she dies, each legendary creature I still control gets as many counters as she had. That makes trading Aerith in combat a lot more tempting. I’d still keep protection handy if an opponent can wipe the whole board at once.

+1/+1 Counters

Crusher gets big on her own, so I usually use Heliod, Sun-Crowned and a leveled-up Cleric Class to put counters on creatures that can make better use of them. A counter on Exemplar of Light can draw a card, and pushing Voice of the Blessed to four counters gives me a flying threat that can stay back to block thanks to vigilance.

Spreading the counters around also sets up Damning Verdict. It destroys creatures without counters, so giving a small utility creature its first counter can matter more than making Crusher even bigger. Check your opponents’ boards before casting it, since their creatures with counters survive too.

Flare of Fortitude can save the board you’ve spent several turns growing. Sacrificing Aerith to cast it can also move her counters onto your other legends. Just remember that Flare locks your life total for the rest of the turn, so it also puts your lifegain triggers on hold.

Best cards for a Dr. Beverly Crusher commander deck

My favorite cards here either keep the life coming in after I’ve passed the turn or give those small gains a job to do. I’d prioritize those cards first when putting together a version of this deck.

Best Life Gain Cards

Soul Warden: Gains you one life whenever another creature enters, including an opponent’s. A token deck can give you several separate lifegain events before you even get back to your turn.

Haliya, Guided by Light: Gains life from your creatures and artifacts entering and can draw a card at your end step if you gained at least three life that turn. With warp, you can get her down for one white mana when you have a turn that can make use of her, then cast her again from exile later.

Pristine Talisman: Makes one colorless mana and gains one life when you tap it. I like leaving it untapped when I can so I can grow Crusher on someone else’s turn or get a draw from Exemplar of Light after I’ve already drawn from it on mine.

Best Life Gain Triggers

Exemplar of Light: Gets a +1/+1 counter whenever you gain life and draws a card the first time each turn you put counters on it. Crusher doubles the lifegain trigger, and gaining life on other players’ turns lets you get more draws around the table.

Well of Lost Dreams: Lets you pay mana to draw up to as many cards as you just gained life. Crusher gives you a second trigger, which makes even a one-life gain worth up to two cards if you have two mana to spare.

Voice of the Blessed: Gets a counter every time you gain life. It gains flying and vigilance at four counters and indestructible at ten, so with Crusher out it can go from a two-drop to a real problem in a couple of turns.

Excalibur II: Picks up a charge counter every time you gain life and gives its wearer +1/+1 for each counter on it. Crusher makes it charge twice as fast. The sword keeps its counters if the equipped creature dies, so your next attacker can pick it up and swing.

Best +1/+1 Counter cards

Heliod, Sun-Crowned: Turns each life gain into a +1/+1 counter on a creature or enchantment you control. The extra trigger from Crusher gives you a choice between growing two threats or putting both counters on the creature that needs them most. Heliod can also give another creature lifelink.

Aerith Gainsborough: Grows whenever you gain life and passes that growth along to each of your surviving legendary creatures when she dies. I like attacking with her once there’s another legend on board that can pick up where she left off.

Nykthos Paragon: Turns a single big life gain into that many counters on each creature you control. You can only take the counters once per turn, even if Crusher gives you an extra trigger. I’d pass on a one-life gain if I have a bigger lifelink hit or Blighted Steppe ready later that turn.

Budget options for a Dr. Beverly Crusher commander deck

I’d start with Ajani’s Welcome, Hinterland Sanctifier, Case of the Uneaten Feast, and Pristine Talisman. They all give the deck repeatable ways to gain life, and the Case can help you cast creatures from your graveyard later if you’ve solved it. Cleric Class is a payoff I’d keep in a lower-budget build because it can improve your life gains, grow a creature, and bring one back as you level it up.

If I were looking for a couple of inexpensive additions, I’d try Soul’s Attendant for another one-drop that sees creatures enter on either side of the table and Abzan Battle Priest to give creatures with +1/+1 counters lifelink. I’d make the first cut from the cards that only gain life once or need a lot of mana before they start helping.

Higher Power/Budget options for a Dr. Beverly Crusher commander deck

These are the upgrades I’d look at if I wanted another way to finish a game, more cards to keep the deck moving, or a way to carry my counters through removal.

Aetherflux Reservoir: Rewards you for chaining spells and turns your life total into a way to deal 50 damage to a target. Its spell trigger gains life once per resolution. Crusher doubles the payoffs that see you gain that life.

Auriok Champion: Gives you another cheap creature that can gain life from creatures entering on either side of the board. Protection from black and red can make it harder for some decks to remove.

Donnie’s Bō: Gives the equipped creature trample and lifelink. This is the Equipment I’d reach for when Crusher is already huge and keeps getting blocked by something small.

Esper Sentinel: Helps you draw cards early when opponents cast their first noncreature spell each turn. Putting counters on it makes the tax harder to pay and gives those counters a job even when you’re holding back on attacks.

Archangel of Thune: Puts a +1/+1 counter on each creature you control whenever you gain life. With Crusher out, every little gain grows your entire board twice.

Inventors’ Fair: Gains a life on your upkeep when you control three artifacts, and it can turn into an artifact tutor once you meet that same requirement. I’d run it in a colorless land slot so I can still reliably cast my white spells.

Ocelot Pride: Gives you a one-mana lifelinker that can make a Cat at your end step if you gained life. The Cats can trigger cards like Soul Warden as they enter, and the city’s blessing lets Pride copy tokens that entered that turn.

The Destined White Mage: Has lifelink, can give another creature lifelink, and lets you put a counter on a creature whenever you gain life. I’d run it as another flexible counter payoff even if I never assemble a full party.

The Ozolith: Stores counters from creatures that leave the battlefield and can move them onto a creature at the start of combat. It gives you somewhere to put Crusher’s counters after removal and a way to get that power back into play.

Mistakes to avoid when building a Dr. Beverly Crusher commander deck

When I look at an opening hand with this deck, I want to know both how I’m gaining life and what I’m getting for it. If I keep drawing hands that can only do one of those things, it’s time to revisit the mix.

Too Much Life Gain

It’s easy to fill the deck with cards that make your life total look impressive. If all they do is buy time, you might still be sitting behind a couple of small creatures while the rest of the table builds toward a win. I’d cut one-shot life gain before touching a card that can do another job, like ramping, drawing cards, or putting a creature on the board.

Not Enough Life Gain

A hand full of payoffs can stall just as easily. If your only way to gain life is attacking with a lifelinker, a crowded board or a removal spell can shut off your whole turn. Keep enough cheap sources that work when creatures enter, when you play lands, or when you tap for mana. Those little gains are what let you keep playing through a board where attacking is a bad idea.

How This Deck Wins

My first plan is to get Crusher big enough to threaten 21 commander damage and use The Wind Crystal to give the team flying and lifelink for the turn. If one opponent keeps leaving themselves open, start getting damage in early. You can also give Excalibur II to a flyer if Crusher has been removed a couple of times and the commander tax is getting expensive.

There’s a wider combat plan with Nykthos Paragon. A big life gain from Blighted Steppe before combat can give the whole team enough power to finish a game. If you’ve reached 50 life in a typical Commander game, Doctor Strange, Surgeon can also give the team +2/+2 and vigilance at the beginning of combat.

Felidar Sovereign is the alternate win in my main deck. It checks for 40 or more life at the beginning of your upkeep and again when the ability resolves, so I’d try to play it when I can protect it through a turn around the table. If you add Aetherflux Reservoir, you get another way to turn that high life total into a win without waiting for an upkeep.

Decklist

This is my main list, with the optional higher-budget cards listed separately in the sideboard.

Example decklist available here: Dr. Beverly Life Gain & Counters

Final Thoughts

My favorite thing about this deck is how quickly a card like Soul Warden can change what the rest of the table is willing to do. Every creature they play can make Crusher bigger, draw me a card, or put another counter on a flyer that’s already giving them trouble. I came into this build expecting a pretty straightforward lifegain deck, and that’s exactly what I like about it. There’s always a little decision to make about where the next counter goes, and before you know it, the Doctor is swinging for lethal.

To pick up a draggable item, press the space bar. While dragging, use the arrow keys to move the item. Press space again to drop the item in its new position, or press escape to cancel.

To pick up a draggable item, press the space bar. While dragging, use the arrow keys to move the item. Press space again to drop the item in its new position, or press escape to cancel.

If you’re looking for another Star Trek commander to build around check out my Best Star Trek commander guide.

No author bio. End of line.

Newest GameTyrant Posts